069 509 586 770Available 24/7 Book an appointment

Comparison · freedom from glasses with high values

ICL or laser?

Adding instead of removing.

High diopters, thin cornea or dry eyes? Up to −6 D, laser is usually the smaller procedure; above −8 D, ICL is usually the better choice. We clarify what suits your eyes in the free initial consultation.

5,0 · 376 Google reviews 12× FOCUS Top Doctor
5,0376 Google reviews
FOCUS Top Doctor 202612× FOCUSTop Doctor
Free initial consultationUsually in 48h ICL or laser? 60-second check

ICL or laser: which is better for high values?

In short.

Up to −6 D, laser eye surgery is usually the smaller, faster and less expensive procedure. Above −8 D, with a thin cornea or dry eyes, the ICL is almost always the better choice, because it removes no tissue and can be removed again. In between, corneal thickness, pupil and eye surface decide, and from about 45 more likely a lens exchange.

ICL is more likely if …

High values, thin cornea or dry eyes.

  • Nearsightedness above −8 D, high farsightedness or strong astigmatism
  • Cornea too thin or irregular for a safe removal
  • Dry eyes, contact lens intolerance
  • You want a lens that can be removed again
  • Age about 21–45, anterior chamber deep enough
Everything about ICL

Rather laser, if …

Values up to −6 D, healthy cornea.

  • Nearsightedness up to −6 D, up to −8 D with a good cornea
  • Normal corneal thickness and shape
  • Calm eye surface without pronounced dryness
  • You want no procedure inside the eye and no yearly check-ups
  • Fastest recovery, lower price
Laser procedures compared

How do the ICL and laser eye surgery differ in numbers?

Five numbers that decide.

Limit

−8 D

Up to this point, we use laser with SMILE Pro or SmartSight. Above it, we recommend ICL. From −6 D, it is possible alongside laser.

Tissue

0 µm

of cornea removed by the ICL. With laser treatment it is roughly 12–15 µm per diopter.

Dry eyes

3 of 10

have dry eyes at first after SMILE Pro. Rarely after the ICL.

Reversible

ICL

can be removed or exchanged. Tissue treated with a laser does not grow back.

Price

from 6,886 €

ICL, both eyes. SMILE Pro €5,198, SmartSight €5,198, Femto-LASIK €4,298, Trans-PRK €3,498.

ICL or LASIK, SMILE Pro, PRK: the big comparison

25 criteria. Four procedures.

Suitability, procedure, recovery, risks with frequency, long term and price side by side. Mint marks which procedure leads on each point. No procedure wins everywhere: the ICL leads with high values, thin cornea and dry eyes, laser treatment with recovery, follow-up effort and price.

← Swipe sideways to compare →

Compare ICL with:

ICL, SMILE Pro/SmartSight, Femto-LASIK and Trans-PRK compared
CriterionICLLens in front of your own lensSMILE ProLaser, keyholeFemto-LASIKLaser with a flapTrans-PRKLaser at the surface
For whom
Nearsightednessup to about −18 Dup to −8 Dup to about −8 Dup to about −6 D
Farsightednessup to about +10 Dnoup to about +4 Dsmall, rare
Astigmatismup to about 6 D (toric ICL)up to 5 Dup to about 6 Dup to about 3 D
Thin corneausually no obstacle, cornea stays untouchedlimit set by remaining thicknessleast favorable choice (flap costs thickness)often still possible, no flap
Dry eyes beforehandbest choice, corneal nerves are preservedpossible with pretreatmentless favorablepossible with pretreatment
Ageabout 21–45 yearsusually from 18, values stable for 12 monthsusually from 18, values stableusually from 18, values stable
Anterior chambermust be deep enough (from about 2.8 mm)irrelevantirrelevantirrelevant
Procedure
What happensFoldable lens is placed in front of your own lens through a 3 mm openingLaser shapes a lens disc in the cornea, removal through a 2–3 mm incisionFlap is lifted, laser shapes underneathLaser removes surface and tissue, without an incision
Tissue removed?noyesyesyes
Durationapprox. 20 min per eyeapprox. 20 min, both eyesapprox. 20 min, both eyesapprox. 20 min
Both eyes on the same day?usually on two daysyesyesyes
Pain afterwardfeeling of pressure, a few hoursforeign-body sensation, a few hoursforeign-body sensation, a few hours4–5 days of noticeable pain possible
Recovery
Sharp visionusually the next dayusually the next dayusually the next dayafter 2 weeks
Work (office)after 1–2 daysafter 1–2 daysafter 1–2 daysafter 5–7 days
Contact sportsafter 2 weeks at the earliest, after consultationafter 2 weeksat the earliest after 2 weeks, the doctor will tell you exactly when (flap protection)after 2 weeks
Side effects and risks
Dry eyes afterwardrare3 in 10 in the first weeksmore often than SMILE Protemporary, weeks
Halos at nightcommon at first, permanently bothersome in a few in 100common in the first weeks, about 5 in 100 after 3 monthssimilar, more with high valuessimilar, more with high values
Typical risktemporary pressure rise up to 2 in 10dry eyesflap problems under 1 in 100scar haze rare
Most serious riskinfection in the eye under 1 in 5,000keratectasia well under 1 in 1,000keratectasia under 1 in 1,000Infection up to about 2 in 1,000
Earlier cataract1–2 in 100 within eight yearsnonono
Enhancement1–2 in 100 size exchange/rotation2 in 100similarsimilar
Long term
Reversibleyes, lens removable or exchangeablenonono
Vision quality at high prescriptionsvery good, no removal neededgood up to −8 Ddecreases at high prescriptionsdecreases at high prescriptions
Follow-up checksannually (pressure, distance, endothelium)not needed after healing is completenot needed after healing is completenot needed after healing is complete
Price both eyesfrom €6,886€5,198€4,298€3,498

Advantage in this criterionPrices: guide prices for both eyes according to GOÄ

Limit values are guide values; in an individual case the pre-operative examination decides. In detail on each procedure: ICL · SMILE Pro · Femto-LASIK · Trans-PRK

From how many diopters is the ICL better than laser?

The higher the prescription, the more the lens is the better choice.

The laser corrects nearsightedness by removing cornea, roughly 12–15 micrometers per diopter in the center. At −4 D this is little, at −10 D a quarter of the corneal thickness is missing. From −8 D we therefore recommend the ICL.

✓

Up to −6 D: laser is the first choice

Small tissue removal, very good night vision, quick recovery. SMILE Pro, SmartSight, Femto-LASIK or Trans-PRK, depending on the cornea. An ICL would be a bigger procedure than necessary here.

✓

−6 to −8 D: both are possible

With a thick cornea and a normal pupil, SMILE Pro and SmartSight are very good. With borderline corneal thickness, large pupils or dryness, the ICL is the better choice. Here we discuss both options with you.

!

Above −8 D: ICL instead of laser

The tissue removal becomes so deep that a smaller optical zone has to be chosen: more halos, less contrast at night and more frequent slight regression of the correction. The ICL does not have this limit.

!

Above −10 D: ICL

ICL corrects up to about −18 D. Many patients see more sharply afterward than they did before with glasses, because glasses make the image smaller at high values.

→

Farsighted above +4 D

Laser reaches its limits sooner with farsightedness than with nearsightedness. Up to about +4 D, Femto-LASIK; above that, ICL up to about +10 D if the anterior chamber is deep enough (at least about 2.8 mm); from age 45, lens exchange is more likely.

→

High astigmatism

SMILE Pro corrects up to 5 D. Above that, or in combination with high prescriptions: toric ICL up to about 6 D.

Read deeper

How much cornea does one diopter cost?

The calculation behind the −8 limit

The laser makes the cornea flatter. How deeply it removes tissue depends on the strength of the correction and on the diameter of the treatment zone. As a rule of thumb, with a 6.5 mm zone, roughly 12–15 µm per diopter. An average cornea is about 530–550 µm thick in the center.

NearsightednessTissue removal (approx.)Classification
−3 D40–45 µmnot a concern
−6 D80–90 µmnot a concern with a normal cornea
−8 D105–120 µmborderline range, corneal thickness decides
−10 D130–150 µmwe advise against it, ICL

After the tissue removal, enough stable tissue must remain so that the cornea does not bulge forward. That is why, at the pre-operative examination, we calculate the residual thickness for each eye before we recommend a laser procedure.

Why do many people see more sharply with an ICL than with glasses?

Image size, contrast and optical zone

Glasses of −10 D sit about 12 mm in front of the eye and noticeably shrink the image; many people know the “small eyes” behind thick lenses from the outside as well. The ICL sits inside the eye, and the image has its natural size again. That is why some patients read one line more on the eye chart after the ICL than before with glasses.

When laser is used for high prescriptions, the optical zone often has to be chosen smaller to save tissue. If the pupil opens wider at night than this zone, light passes through the transition area: halos and loss of contrast. The ICL has a fixed optic and does not remove any tissue.

Does the result stay stable at high prescriptions?

Regression of the correction

After laser treatment, the top cell layer of the cornea thickens slightly and offsets part of the correction. At low prescriptions this hardly matters; at high prescriptions, a remainder of 0.5 to 1 D can return. The ICL does not show this effect, because nothing on the cornea is changed. This must be distinguished from progressive nearsightedness of the eye itself; that is why, for all procedures, the prescription must be stable for at least one year.

ICL or laser with a thin cornea?

Little cornea, little room to work with.

Below about 500 µm central thickness we speak of a thin cornea; about 1 in 10 patients have this. Then it depends on the prescription: with low diopters, Trans-PRK is often still possible; with higher ones, the ICL. Femto-LASIK is usually ruled out.

✓

ICL: corneal thickness does not matter

The ICL is placed behind the iris. The cornea is opened only at the edge for a 3 mm access, and its thickness and stability remain. That is why the ICL is the standard solution for a thin cornea with medium to high prescriptions.

✓

Trans-PRK: no flap, more remaining tissue

The surface treatment needs no cover (flap) and no pocket. For the same prescription, it leaves the most load-bearing tissue. With a thin cornea and prescriptions up to about −4 to −5 D, often the best laser option. Price: €3,498 for both eyes.

→

SMILE Pro: in individual cases

No flap, and the upper corneal layers stay largely intact. With borderline thickness and low prescriptions, sometimes possible if the residual thickness is sufficient. We calculate this for each eye individually.

!

Femto-LASIK and keratoconus: no

The flap costs an additional 90–110 µm of load-bearing capacity. With a thin cornea, we advise against it. With keratoconus or suspected keratoconus, we do not use laser at all; then cross-linking is considered and, once the cornea is stable, the ICL.

Read deeper

How is the cornea measured?

Thickness, shape and back surface

We measure not only the thickness at the center but the entire cornea in 3D (tomography): front and back surface, the thinnest point, the thickness distribution. An early keratoconus often shows up first on the back surface, long before it changes your vision. These are exactly the eyes that must not be treated with laser. In addition, there is epithelial thickness and, if needed, biomechanics.

What is the residual thickness and why does it matter?

Safety limits for laser treatment

After laser treatment, enough firm tissue must remain beneath the treated zone. Common safety limits are a residual stroma of at least 250–300 µm and a share of altered tissue of no more than about 40% of the total thickness. We apply the limits rather conservatively. If you are just below them, we will not offer you laser treatment but a different recommendation.

And if another practice told me “too thin”?

Second opinion with our own measurements

“Too thin” usually means: too thin for Femto-LASIK. For Trans-PRK or ICL it can still be suitable. Bring existing findings; we measure again ourselves and explain which options remain. More on Laser eye surgery with a thin cornea and second opinion.

ICL or laser with dry eyes?

The nerves decide.

Tear flow is controlled by nerves in the cornea. Every laser procedure cuts some of them, the ICL does not. After SMILE Pro, 3 in 10 have dry eyes in the first weeks, after LASIK more. Anyone who already has dry eyes beforehand or does not tolerate contact lenses is usually better served with the ICL.

ProceduresWhat happens to the corneal nervesDry eyes afterwardWith dry eyes beforehand
ICLremain untouched, access at the edgerare, brief because of dropsbest choice
SMILE Prosmall incision of 2–3 mm, upper nerve layer largely intact3 in 10 in the first weeks, usually gone after 3–6 monthspossible after treatment of the dry eye
Femto-LASIKflap incision all the way around, nerves severed except for one bridgemore frequent and longer than after SMILE Proless favorable
Trans-PRKsurface nerves are removed, regrowa few weekspossible after treatment
1

We measure beforehand

Tear film break-up time, tear volume, eyelid margins, meibomian glands and the surface under the microscope. Many cases of “dry eyes” are an inflammation of the eyelid margin, which can be treated well.

2

We treat beforehand

Eyelid margin care, preservative-free artificial tears and, if needed, light therapy. Only when the surface has calmed down do we measure a second time and decide.

3

We decide honestly

If the surface stays sensitive or you have not tolerated contact lenses for years, we recommend the ICL, even at prescriptions that could be treated with laser.

How long dryness lasts after laser treatment and what helps: Dry eyes after laser eye surgery · Treatment: Dry eye

What risks do ICL and laser eye surgery have in comparison?

Different risks. Serious ones are rare with both.

The safety rate for procedures by Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari is 99.9%. The difference lies in the type of risks: with laser treatment they concern the cornea, above all dry eyes. With the ICL the eye is opened; rare consequences are a rise in pressure, earlier clouding of your own lens and, very rarely, an infection in the eye, under 1 in 5,000.

RiskICLLaser eye surgery (SMILE Pro, SmartSight, LASIK, PRK)What we do
Dry eyesrare, the corneal nerves are not severed3 in 10 in the first weeks after SMILE Pro, more frequent after LASIK; usually gone after 3–6 monthsMeasure and treat the tear film beforehand; with pronounced dryness, we advise the ICL
Halos, glareoften at first; persistently bothersome in a few of 100frequent in the first weeks, about 5 in 100 after 3 months; more frequent with increasing dioptersMeasure the pupil in darkness, match the optical zone to it
Eye pressuretemporary up to 2 in 10 in the first days; permanent about 1 in 100 in ten yearsnot a typical risk; cortisone drops can raise the pressure brieflyPressure measurement after hours and on the following day, drops if needed
Earlier cataract1–2 in 100 in eight years with modern ICLs, more frequent over 40no increased riskCalculate the size exactly, measure the distance annually; from 45, lens exchange is more likely
Endothelial cellsLong-term studies show no significant loss with modern ICLs beyond what comes with agenot affectedCount the cells before surgery and annually
Corneal bulging (ectasia)no risk, no tissue removalwell below 1 in 1,000 after SMILE Pro with careful selection; higher with a thin or abnormal corneaCorneal tomography, calculating residual thickness, not treating borderline cases with laser
Infectioninside the eye, below 1 in 5,000on the cornea, below 1 in 1,000 (after PRK up to about 2 in 1,000)Sterile procedure, drops, follow-up check the day after the procedure, emergency number around the clock
EnhancementSize exchange or rotation 1–2 in 1002 in 100 after SMILE ProOnly after stable prescriptions, at the earliest after 3 months

Frequencies from the literature and our own evaluation (SMILE Pro: n = 412, 01/2024–01/2026).

Evening highway drive from the driver’s point of view with oncoming traffic at dusk
No effect

Simplified depiction. Photo: Patrick Tomasso, Unsplash (CC0).

Night vision: tap an effect. The photo shows what it looks like.

Read deeper

Is a procedure inside the eye more dangerous?

What “intraocular” means and what it does not

With the ICL, the eye is opened through a 3 mm access, similar to cataract surgery, the most common procedure in medicine. That is more than a treatment on the corneal surface, and it carries risks that do not exist with laser, above all an infection inside the eye. It is very rare but serious; that is why we usually operate on the two eyes on separate days and have an emergency number around the clock.

Conversely, laser has risks that do not exist with the ICL: permanently dry eyes and, very rarely, a bulging of the cornea. At high prescriptions these laser risks increase, while with the ICL they stay the same. That is why the balance tips in favor of the ICL from about −8 D.

What does the annual check after ICL involve?

Pressure, distance, endothelium

After an ICL, you should come for a check once a year: eye pressure, distance between the ICL and your own lens (vault) and the number of endothelial cells. This takes about 30 minutes and can also take place at your local eye doctor. After laser treatment, once healing is complete, occasional checks with your eye doctor make sense, because an ectasia very rarely appears only after years.

What if something goes wrong?

Treatment paths for both procedures

ICL: if the size does not fit, it is exchanged; if the pressure rises, drops or a small laser help; if your own lens clouds, both lenses are exchanged for an artificial lens in one surgery. Laser treatment: residual values are enhanced, dry eyes treated, a bulging usually stabilized with cross-linking. More on Laser eye surgery: risks and Safety & aftercare.

Strengths and weaknesses: ICL and laser eye surgery at a glance

What you gain. What you accept.

Both paths usually make you glasses-free. The ICL scores with image quality at high prescriptions, protection of the cornea and reversibility; laser with the smaller procedure, the quicker recovery and the lower price of €3,498 to €5,198 for both eyes.

ICL

Add a lens.

Strengths

  • Very good image quality even at −10 D and more
  • No tissue removed, the cornea stays stable
  • Dry eyes rare and usually only brief
  • Removable and replaceable
  • No regression of the correction from corneal healing

Weaknesses

  • Procedure inside the eye, usually on two days
  • Rare risks: pressure, earlier clouding of the lens, infection in the eye
  • Annual check
  • More expensive: from €6,886 for both eyes
  • From about 45, a borderline case because of presbyopia and clouding of the lens

Laser eye surgery

Shape the cornea.

Strengths

  • No procedure inside the eye, both eyes on one day
  • Back to work usually after 1–2 days (SMILE Pro/SmartSight, Femto-LASIK)
  • No checks after healing is complete
  • Less expensive: €3,498 to €5,198
  • Long-term experience over decades

Weaknesses

  • Not reversible, tissue is removed
  • Dry eyes often at first (3 in 10 after SMILE Pro)
  • At high prescriptions more halos and slight regression
  • Limited by corneal thickness and shape
Read deeper

What happens later with cataract?

ICL wearers and laser patients in older age

Almost everyone gets a cataract, usually after 60. In ICL wearers, the ICL and the clouded lens are then removed in one operation and replaced with an artificial lens that also corrects the nearsightedness. After laser treatment, cataract surgery is just as possible; the calculation of the artificial lens is slightly less accurate because the cornea has been changed. Keep your prescription from before the laser treatment; it helps the surgeon decades later.

And reading glasses from 45?

Presbyopia affects both

Neither the ICL nor laser treatment prevents presbyopia. From about 45, ICL wearers and people treated with a laser also need reading glasses for near vision. Anyone who is already over 45 should choose a procedure that addresses distance and near vision right away: Presbyond or a lens exchange. You can find the comparison under Lens exchange or Presbyond?

Bioptics: ICL plus laser

When both make sense

With very high prescriptions and additional high astigmatism, it can make sense to insert the ICL first and correct a small remainder with the laser after a few months. The laser then has to remove only a little tissue. This is the exception; most patients need only one of the two.

ICL or laser: what suits my eyes?

Four questions. A first orientation.

Tap what applies to you. The recommendation follows the limits we also apply in consultation hours: diopters, cornea, eye surface, age. It does not replace a measurement, but it shows you what we will talk about with you.

How strong is your nearsightedness?The higher value of your two eyes. It is on your glasses prescription (sphere).
What do you know about your cornea?Often listed in the findings of an earlier LASIK check.
How are your eyes in everyday life?
How old are you?

Your orientation

SMILE Pro

    More about SMILE Pro Schedule the pre-operative examination

    Guidance, not a diagnosis. Whether a procedure is suitable is decided by measurements in the pre-operative examination (corneal tomography, anterior chamber depth, endothelial cells, tear film).

    What do ICL and laser eye surgery cost in comparison?

    Guide prices for both eyes.

    At dr.vision, ICL costs from €6,886 for both eyes, SMILE Pro €5,198, SmartSight €5,198, Femto-LASIK €4,298 and Trans-PRK €3,498, billed privately under the German fee schedule for physicians (GOÄ). You will receive the written cost estimate after the pre-operative examination, before you decide.

    Over −8 D

    ICL

    Two custom-made lenses, a more extensive pre-operative examination, usually two surgery appointments.

    Included
    Pre-operative examination, lenses, surgery on both eyes, aftercare

    from €6,886both eyes

    Up to −8 D

    SMILE Pro

    Keyhole laser, gentle on the corneal nerves, ZEISS VisuMax 800.

    Included
    Pre-operative examination, treatment of both eyes, aftercare

    €5,198both eyes · from €3.90 a day*

    Up to −8 D

    SmartSight

    Keyhole laser like SMILE Pro, with the SCHWIND ATOS.

    Included
    Pre-operative examination, treatment of both eyes, aftercare

    €5,198both eyes

    Also farsightedness

    Femto-LASIK

    Laser with a flap, also for farsightedness up to about +4 D.

    Included
    Pre-operative examination, treatment of both eyes, aftercare

    €4,298both eyes

    Thin cornea

    Trans-PRK

    Surface treatment without an incision, longer healing.

    Included
    Pre-operative examination, treatment of both eyes, aftercare

    €3,498both eyes

    Guide prices for both eyes under the GOÄ, not a fixed price. * Representative example SMILE Pro: €5,198 net loan amount · 72 months · fixed borrowing rate 9.49% p.a. · 9.90% effective annual interest rate · monthly installment €94.97 · total amount €6,837.84 · via medipay. Example 0% over 12 months directly with dr.vision: €5,198 cash price · no down payment · fixed borrowing rate 0% p.a. · 0% effective annual interest rate · monthly installment €433.17, last installment €433.13 · total amount €5,198.

    Private health insurance

    Many private health insurers reimburse laser eye surgery and ICL proportionally depending on the plan; a personal share usually remains. We write the cost estimate so that your insurance can give a clear answer in advance. More on private health insurance

    Beihilfe

    The Beihilfe (allowance for German civil servants) reimburses refractive procedures only in exceptional cases, varying by federal state. We check with you whether your case qualifies. More on the Beihilfe

    Statutory health insurance

    dr.vision is a private practice without statutory health insurance accreditation; you pay yourself, according to a written cost estimate. You can list the costs as extraordinary expenses in your tax return. Whether and how much the tax office recognizes depends, among other things, on your reasonable burden. More · Tax

    Calculate the monthly installment for your procedure: Financing & monthly installment · All prices: Prices & costs

    Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari in the examination room at dr.vision

    Who decides at dr.vision whether ICL or laser?

    A doctor who does both.

    Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari performs ICL and laser procedures himself. He has no reason to sell you one or the other: at dr.vision, laser (ZEISS VisuMax 800) and lens surgery are in one hand. Over 20,000 procedures, 12× FOCUS Top Doctor.

    20.000+Procedures by Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari
    99.9%Safety rate
    376Google reviews, average 5.0
    12×FOCUS Top Doctor 2026, refractive surgery and cataract
    FOCUS Top Doctor
    Patient Care at dr.vision

    ICL or laser? Unsure?

    We measure. Then you will know.

    Jana from our Patient Care team answers your questions and arranges the pre-operative examination with Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari. You go home with a clear recommendation. Call around the clock, WhatsApp Mon–Fri 8:00–19:00, Sat 9:00–15:00.

    What are patient experiences with laser eye surgery at dr.vision?

    376 reviews. Average 5.0.

    376 Google reviews give dr.vision an average of 5.0 out of 5 stars. dr.vision does not check whether Google reviews come from treated patients.

    “Without time pressure, he advised me in a trustworthy, calm, open and competent way and involved me well in the decision about how to proceed.”
    K B · Google
    “I had researched intensively beforehand and knew that laser treatment was not an option for me - I absolutely wanted an ICL.”
    Jonas · Google
    “Prof. Dr. Shajari advised me extremely competently, thoroughly and clearly, and gave me a very good and safe feeling from the start.”
    pedda 454 · Google
    “The laser surgery went great! Many thanks to Prof. Shajari for the friendly and professional treatment!”
    Peter S · Google

    How do patients experience ICL and laser eye surgery at dr.vision?

    Four patients. In their own words.

    ICLDominic BoeschenSuddenly reading at a distance – a new world.
    ICLDr. Arlett HovakimianI really had a pleasant impression.
    SMILE ProRaquel Schulze WischelerIt is an absolute liberation.
    Femto-LASIKTeresa SchwengerIt was a very good decision to come here.

    Frequently asked questions: ICL or laser eye surgery

    Still have questions?

    These are the questions patients ask most often in the consultation hours about this comparison. Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari

    From how many diopters is the ICL better than laser eye surgery?

    Up to −6 D, laser is usually the first choice with a normal cornea. Between −6 and −8 D, both paths are options; the corneal thickness, the pupil size and the eye surface decide. Above −8 D we recommend the ICL, because the laser would then have to remove so much tissue that vision quality and stability suffer.

    Can −10 diopters be treated with laser?

    Technically it is sometimes possible with a very thick cornea, but at dr.vision we do not use laser above −8 D. For −10 D, the laser would remove roughly 130 to 150 micrometers of cornea. Night vision gets worse, the correction regresses slightly more often, and the cornea is weakened. The ICL corrects −10 D without tissue removal and with very good image quality.

    What is the better choice with a thin cornea?

    With a thin cornea, Femto-LASIK is usually ruled out because the flap costs additional thickness. With low prescriptions, Trans-PRK is often still possible; with higher prescriptions or a very thin cornea, the ICL, because it leaves the cornea untouched. With suspected keratoconus, we do not use laser.

    Which procedure is better for dry eyes?

    The ICL. It is inserted through a small access at the edge of the cornea and does not sever the corneal nerves that control tear flow. After laser treatment, dry eyes are frequent in the first weeks, about 3 in 10 after SMILE Pro, more frequent after LASIK. We treat mild dryness beforehand; with pronounced dryness, we advise the ICL.

    Is the ICL safer than laser eye surgery?

    With both, serious complications are rare, but the risks are different. With laser, they affect the cornea (dry eyes, very rarely a bulging). With the ICL, the eye is opened; rare risks are a rise in pressure, earlier clouding of your own lens and an infection in the eye. With prescriptions up to −6 D, laser is the smaller procedure; above −8 D, the ICL is the safer choice.

    Do I have more halos after ICL or after laser?

    In the first weeks, many people see halos after both procedures. After SMILE Pro, they still bother about 5 in 100 after three months. With high prescriptions, night vision tends to decrease after laser because the treatment zone has to be chosen smaller; there the ICL usually does better. We measure the pupil in darkness and discuss the risk beforehand.

    Can the ICL be removed again, and can laser be reversed?

    The ICL, yes: it can be removed or exchanged for a different size, through the same small access. Laser cannot be reversed, because the removed tissue does not grow back. Remaining prescription after laser can often be enhanced, though; after SMILE Pro this is needed in about 2 in 100.

    What happens to the ICL if I get a cataract later?

    Then the ICL and your clouded own lens are removed in one operation and replaced with an artificial lens. This is a routine procedure. After laser treatment, cataract surgery is also quite possible; the calculation of the artificial lens is then slightly less accurate, so bring your old laser values.

    Do I need reading glasses from 45 after ICL or laser?

    Yes, in both cases. Both correct the refractive error, not the presbyopia that sets in from about 45. If you are already over 45, you should therefore consider Presbyond or a lens exchange, which addresses distance and near vision together.

    Can ICL and laser eye surgery be combined?

    Yes. With very high prescriptions and high astigmatism, we sometimes insert the ICL first and correct a small remaining value later with the laser. This combination is called bioptics. It is the exception, not the rule.

    Why is the ICL more expensive than laser eye surgery?

    For ICL, an individually made lens is ordered for each eye, and there is also a more extensive pre-operative examination (anterior chamber depth, endothelial cells) and usually two surgery appointments. At dr.vision, ICL costs from €6,886 for both eyes, SMILE Pro €5,198, SmartSight €5,198, Femto-LASIK €4,298 and Trans-PRK €3,498, each as a guide price under the GOÄ.

    Does health insurance pay for ICL or laser eye surgery?

    Statutory health insurance usually does not; dr.vision is a private practice, and patients with statutory health insurance pay themselves. Private health insurers reimburse a share depending on the plan, more often with high prescriptions as with the ICL. Beihilfe pays only in exceptional cases, which differ by federal state. You can declare the costs as extraordinary expenses in your tax return. Whether and how much the tax office accepts depends, among other things, on your reasonable burden.

    Medically reviewed by Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari · As of October 2026

    Can I take the ICL or laser comparison with me?

    Everything to read and pass on.

    • The large comparison tableICL, SMILE Pro/SmartSight, Femto-LASIK, Trans-PRK in 25 criteria
    • Risks side by sideWith frequencies and what we do about them
    • Pre-operative examination checklistWhich measurements decide and which questions you should ask
    Prefer to have it sent by WhatsApp

    Arrives by e-mail in about 60 seconds. No newsletter, just the guide and, if you wish, a follow-up from Patient Care. Privacy policy

    How do I find out whether ICL or laser suits me?

    How would you like to continue?

    It begins with a free consultation. This is followed by the detailed pre-operative examination with Prof. Dr. Mehdi Shajari: corneal tomography, anterior chamber depth, endothelial cells, tear film and pupil in darkness, plus a talk about whether ICL or laser is safer for you. You go home with a written recommendation and a cost estimate.

    I would like an appointment

    Free initial consultation

    I am coming from near

    In Frankfurt, Junghofstraße 16 · all measurements included

    Next available appointment Tue, Oct 27 · 10:15
    Book a free initial consultation ★ 5.0 · 376 Google reviews · 12× FOCUS Top Doctor
    I still have questions

    Talk first

    Jana online
    Reply usually within 10–15 min · Mon–Fri 8:00–19:00, Sat 9:00–15:00
    Ask via WhatsApp Call 069 509 586 770Available 24 hours
    Request a callback

    Where are ICL and laser eye surgery performed at dr.vision?

    Our locations.

    dr.vision practice, FrankfurtOpening hours

    Frankfurt

    Junghofstraße 16, 60311 Frankfurt am Main

    Mon–Fri
    8:00–19:00
    Sat
    9:00–15:00
    • Phone069 509 586 770 · available 24 hours
    • ParkingFree in the building (Junghofstraße parking garage)
    • Public transitHauptwache (S/U), 5 min on foot
    Plan route
    Rooms at the Düsseldorf locationOpening 2027

    Düsseldorf2027

    Breite Straße 69, 40213 Düsseldorf (in the Neuer Stahlhof, corner of Graf-Adolf-Platz)

    Mon–Fri
    8:00–19:00
    Sat
    9:00–15:00
    • Phone069 509 586 770 · available 24 hours
    • ParkingQ-Park GAP 15 at Graf-Adolf-Platz, 3 min on foot
    • Public transitGraf-Adolf-Platz (subway, streetcar), 4 min on foot

    Until opening: preliminary talk in Frankfurt, Patient Care plans your travel.

    Plan route
    Reception at the Stuttgart locationOpening 2027

    Stuttgart2027

    Lautenschlagerstraße 23, 70173 Stuttgart (2nd floor, step-free access)

    Mon–Fri
    8:00–19:00
    Sat
    9:00–15:00
    • Phone069 509 586 770 · available 24 hours
    • Public transitBörsenplatz (subway), 2 min on foot; main station 5 min

    Until opening: preliminary talk in Frankfurt, Patient Care plans your travel.

    Plan route
    Sources and further reading
    1. Refractive Surgery Commission (KRC) of DOG and BVA: Bewertung und Qualitätssicherung refraktiv-chirurgischer Eingriffe, as of 05/2024, bva.dog/krc/qualit.pdf
    2. Kamiya K, Shimizu K, Takahashi M et al.: Eight-Year Outcomes of Implantation of Posterior Chamber Phakic Intraocular Lens With a Central Port for Moderate to High Ametropia. Front Med 2021;8:799078. doi:10.3389/fmed.2021.799078
    3. Case report of LASIK in one eye and ICL in the other over 9 years, PubMed 18041249.
    4. Cai WT, Liu QY, Ren CD et al.: Dry eye and corneal sensitivity after small incision lenticule extraction and femtosecond laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis: a Meta-analysis. Int J Ophthalmol 2017;10(4):632–638. doi:10.18240/ijo.2017.04.21
    5. dr.vision's own analysis, SMILE Pro 01/2024–01/2026, n = 412
    Limit

    −8 diopters.

    SMILE Pro corrects nearsightedness up to −8 D and astigmatism up to 5 D. Above that, the tissue removal becomes so deep that night vision and stability suffer. The ICL corrects up to about −18 D without removing cornea.

    To the high prescriptions
    Tissue

    Adding instead of removing.

    The laser removes roughly 12–15 micrometers of cornea per diopter, the ICL none. With a thin cornea or high prescriptions, this is the decisive difference.

    To the thin cornea
    Dry eyes

    The nerves stay.

    After SMILE Pro, 3 in 10 have dry eyes in the first weeks, more after LASIK. The ICL does not sever any corneal nerves. If you cannot tolerate contact lenses, you are usually better served with it.

    To the dry eyes
    Reversible

    The ICL can come out again.

    It can be removed or exchanged for a different size. With laser, the tissue is removed; remaining prescription can be enhanced, but not reversed.

    Strengths and weaknesses
    Price

    Guide prices for both eyes.

    ICL from €6,886, SMILE Pro €5,198, SmartSight €5,198, Femto-LASIK €4,298, Trans-PRK €3,498. Billing under the GOÄ, written cost estimate after the pre-operative examination.

    To the costs

    Arrange an appointment